Sports News
| Published On Oct 11, 2023 7:16 am CEST  |  Updated on Nov 10, 2025 4:58 am CET | By iGaming Team

Odds and Ends: How Bookmakers Evaluate Melbourne Cup Horses

Share

The Melbourne Cup started in 1861, and since then, it has grown to be the premier racing event in Australia. Today, it’s known as the richest handicap race in the world, with total prize money of more than AUD$10 million.

The ‘race that stops a nation,’ as the event is known, is held every second Tuesday of November. This year’s race will be on November 7, and for many Australians, this is the day for betting. In 2021, the total amount of money wagered on the Melbourne Cup reached more than AUD$ 220 million.

And if you’re one of those who plan to take a flutter on that day, know that you’ll be betting against the bookmakers. They play a vital role in the Melbourne Cup as they set the odds for each horse.

Horses for the Melbourne Cup are from all over the world. Hundreds are nominated, but only up to 24 horses are accepted.

Odds and betting markets

Odds and betting markets may seem daunting at first, but they’re just simple mathematical tables that anyone can understand.

Get 125% / $2,500 on 1st deposit!
New players only. Exclusive Welcome Bonus of up to $2,500
Casino & Sports

The odds for each horse in the Melbourne Cup race are expressed in dollar terms. For example, a horse may be priced at AUD$2.00, AUD$4.50, AUD$10.00, or AUD$41.00. This number represents the market’s assessment of the horse’s chances of winning the race.

To calculate the horse’s implied probability of winning, simply divide one by the price. For example:

1 / AUD$2 = 50%

1 / AUD$4.50 = 22.2%

Get 125% / $2,500 on 1st deposit!
New players only. Exclusive Welcome Bonus of up to $2,500
Casino & Sports

1 / AUD$10 = 10%

1 / AUD$41 = 2.4%

If a 2/1 shot wins, you’ll receive two units (or dollars) for every unit you bet, plus your initial stake. So, an AUD$10 bet would return AUD$30. Similarly, if a 7/2 shot wins, you’ll receive seven units for every two units you bet, plus your initial stake. So, an AUD$10 bet would return AUD$35.

Of course, everyone has different opinions on a horse’s chances of winning. The market, as represented by bookmakers, is simply the aggregate of these opinions, weighted by the amount of money bet on each horse. You may personally believe that a horse has a better chance of winning than its price suggests.

In this case, you’d say that the horse is ‘under the odds’ or ‘underbet.’ The opposite is true if you believe a horse is overpriced, ‘over the odds,’ or ‘overbet.’

The role of bookmakers in setting the odds

Bookmakers are individuals or companies that accept and pay out bets on sporting and other events at agreed-upon odds.

Get 125% / $2,500 on 1st deposit!
New players only. Exclusive Welcome Bonus of up to $2,500
Casino & Sports

In horse racing betting, bookmakers play a vital role by providing a marketplace for punters to place their bets. They establish the odds for each horse in a race, acting as the scale against which bettors measure risk and reward.

These odds reflect the bookmaker’s assessment of a horse’s probability of winning. Punters use these them as the basis for backing a favourite, seeking value in an underdog, or using more sophisticated betting strategies.

The odds set by the bookmakers act as a reference point that dictates the betting landscape of sports events like the Melbourne Cup.

Factors considered by bookmakers

Several factors influence the mathematical expressions punters rely on to make betting decisions. These include the following:

1. Form and performance

A horse’s current form is like its resume, a record of its past performances. Bookmakers carefully analyse how well a horse has been performing in recent races. Strong recent showings often result in shorter odds, reflecting the horse’s current competitiveness.

Bookmakers also consider key performance indicators such as finishing positions, margin of victory, and consistency. These metrics provide insights into a horse’s abilities and consistency, helping bookmakers refine their odds.

2. Jockey and trainer

Jockeys and trainers play a crucial role in a horse’s performance. Bookmakers highly regard experienced and successful jockey-trainer combinations, as they can significantly enhance a horse’s chances. A top-tier jockey paired with a renowned trainer often leads to shorter odds.

For example, the partnership between jockey Glen Boss and trainer Bart Cummings resulted in three consecutive Melbourne Cup victories with Makybe Diva from 2003 to 2005. More on the importance of a jockey can be found here.

3. Track conditions

The racetrack’s condition is a variable that bookmakers closely monitor. A wet or heavy track can favour certain horses, while a firm one may benefit others. Bookmakers adjust odds based on anticipated track conditions, ensuring they reflect the changing dynamics of the race.

Moreover, some horses excel on particular track surfaces. For instance, a horse may have a strong track record on turf but struggle on synthetic tracks. Bookmakers account for these preferences in their odds.

4. Weight and barrier draw

The horse’s weight and starting position in the barrier draw can significantly impact its performance.

Bookmakers assess how weight and barrier draw affect a horse’s chances in a specific race. Horses with favourable weights and barrier positions may see shorter odds, while others may see their odds lengthen due to less favourable conditions.

5. Public opinion and market trends

Statistics and analysis of the factors above aren’t the only factors bookmakers consider. They also use public sentiment and market dynamics. Here’s how:

Impact of public sentiment

High-profile horses with a strong following can sway bookmaker odds. When a popular horse gains traction with the public sentiment, bookmakers may shorten the odds in response to the increased demands for bets on that particular horse. On the other hand, a horse’s lack of support from the betting public can lead to longer odds.

Bookmakers would adjust the odds to balance risk and encourage betting on the other horses.

Market trends and fluctuations

Market trends reflect the sentiment of the betting community. For example, when a significant number of punters back a certain horse, its odds will shorten.

Trends like these are often affected by factors like social media popularity and insider tips. Accordingly, bookmakers keep an eye on these developments when determining the odds.

Balancing the books to minimise risk

Bookmakers aim to maintain a balanced book or roughly equal amounts of money wagered on each horse in a race. This minimises their risk and ensures a profit regardless of the outcome.

To achieve this balance, bookmakers may adjust odds in real time as bets come in. If one horse attracts a disproportionate amount of bets, its odds may lengthen to encourage betting on other contenders.

Conclusion

Bookmakers evaluate horses based on various factors, including recent form, jockey-trainer combinations, track conditions, and weight allocation. These shape the odds for each horse, providing punters with a roadmap for navigating the Melbourne Cup betting landscape.

Understanding how bookmakers operate and the significance of odds is essential for making informed betting decisions. It can help punters identify value, favourites, and underdogs and guide them through the excitement of the Melbourne Cup.